Balancing the Powers

SCOTUS appears poised to expand presidential power over independent agencies.

On Monday, justices heard a case about President Trump’s removal of FTC Commissioner Rebecca Kelly Slaughter, one of a dozen officials fired from independent agencies created to be insulated from political influence. A majority signaled they may curb or overturn a 1935 precedent limiting presidents from firing these agency leaders over policy differences.

Conservative justices seemed sympathetic to the argument that independent agencies in the executive branch (like the FTC) raise “constitutional problems” by giving “unaccountable” unelected leaders significant power. Liberal justices voiced concerns about giving a president “unchecked power” to replace experts that Congress meant to be outside political pressures.   

Both sides of the bench note that the FTC ruling (expected by June) won’t automatically affect other agencies—including the Federal Reserve, which faces a similar case next month.

ETERNAL PERSPECTIVE
When stories raise questions about who has power and how much they have, Christians remember that our hope isn’t in perfect systems but in a powerful King who rules with justice, humility, wisdom, and peace. We’re called to pray that our leaders use their power in the same way.

“Almighty God, our heavenly Father, send down on those who hold public office the spirit of wisdom, charity, and justice; that with steadfast purpose they may faithfully serve in their offices to promote the well-being of all people; through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen”  
Book of Common Prayer, page 655